Business Owners' and Professionals' Financial Dilemma:
"How do I get enough money out of my business or practice to increase my personal well-being when TAXES are eating me alive?"
"Over and
over again, courts have held that there is nothing sinister in arranging one's
affairs to keep taxes as low as possible. Everybody does so, rich and poor,
and all do right because nobody owes any public duty to pay more than the law
demands. Taxes are enforced extractions, not voluntary contributions."
...Judge Learned Hand
WBT Details
A multiple employer trust is authorized under Section 419A(f)(6) of the Internal Revenue code. This section helps chart a course to provide certain types of benefits for employees of the sponsoring employer.
A Welfare Benefit Trust can be established by virtually any corporation, large or small, for the benefit of its employees, including owner-employees and are utilized by thousands of businesses and professionals throughout the country.
Assets
of the plan must be available to satisfy claims of all participants.
Welfare
Benefit Trusts are a powerful wealth preservation and tax deferral tool
allowed by law.
A
Welfare Benefit Trust is not a retirement plan, or a form of deferred
compensation.
Contributions
are tax deductible and are not included in current income of the employee.
Welfare Benefit Trust assets when funded with life insurance grow tax deferred. If withdrawn from the trust, they are then taxed as ordinary income.
The Welfare Benefit Trust preserves your wealth
Option 1 (No Plan)
Option 2 (Traditional Qualified Plans)
Option 3 (Welfare Benefit Trust) - Typical Example
The Welfare Benefit Trust provides an effective supplement to traditional qualified plans and an alternative to deferred compensation plans. For more information, Read On!
7 Rules for Accumulating Wealth
Flexible funding as to the amount of contributions.
Allow large contributions in peak earning years and smaller or no contributions in lean years.
Favors the business owner.
Plan assets can grow tax-deferred.
Allow premature or late distributions without penalty.
Financial Security.
Reasonable to set up and administer.
Uses of a Multiple Employer Benefit Trust
Business & Personal Planning Opportunities with a Welfare Benefit Trust
How does a WBT work?
Qualified Participants
Only full-time employees (1,000 + hours) who have completed between 1 to 3 years of service and are 21 or over are eligible to participate. (Seasonal and union employees are also excluded.)
Death Benefit Only
The Employer will provide a death benefit for all eligible participants.
Plan Termination
The employer can modify or terminate the plan at any time.
WBT Advantages
When properly structured a Welfare Benefit Trust can be designed so that the benefits paid from the trust will not be included in the estate for estate tax purposes. This is because the participants will have no "incidents of ownership" in the assets, including life insurance contracts held under the Welfare Benefit Trust. This is due to the following:
Wouldn't it be a shame to build a large pool of money and then lose it overnight, and probably not have enough time to rebuild that nest egg? While assets are held in a Welfare Benefit Trust, they may be protected from personal & business creditors.
Not only do you have the advantage that Welfare Benefit Trust assets can grow tax-deferred, but you also have the advantage that the assets of the plan are considered to be an unallocated reserve.
The assets are not in any participant's name. In addition, regulations provide that the assets may never revert to the business and is for the exclusive benefit of the participants and their beneficiaries.
How safe is a WBT?
In 1989 & 1991 the tax court agreed that contributions made to a Welfare Benefit Plan which substantially exceeded the limitations of qualified plans, were permissible. In Moser vs. Commissioner and Joel A. Schneider, MD vs. Commissioner, the tax court upheld the taxpayer's position, even though 98% of the contributions were attributable to the benefit of Moser & Schneider. There is no statutory or regulatory provision that prohibits a deduction merely because a high portion of the benefits are attributable to one employee or a group of employees.
The specific information detailing these cases is available upon request.
Other favorable cases that are noteworthy which were favorable to the tax payer and Welfare Benefit Plans are:
Water Quality Assoc. Employers Benefit Corp vs. US
Greensboro Pathology Assoc., P.A. vs. US
American Association of Christian Schools VEBA Welfare Trust vs. US
Grant Jacoby, Inc. vs. US
Who should consider a WBT?
Because
of the favorable benefits of a 419A(f)(6) Welfare Benefit Trust, we have found
that the following businesses should consider establishing one:
|
||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
|
|||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
|
|||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
WBT Conclusion
The owner(s) of a prosperous small to medium sized business or professional corporation determine the amount of first year's contribution based upon their need to mitigate taxation and their need for tax deductible benefits. The contributions are fully deductible, as are the costs for establishing the plan. The value of the benefit is not included in the income of participants until paid out (exception, the economic value PS58 cost). The tax deferred and deductible employee benefits usually favor business and professional owner(s) because of the disparity in income and years of service. This ratio helps to keep the cost of the benefits to ancillary employees low. The trustee purchases life insurance benefits from highly rated and financially sound insurance carriers. Assets of the trust may be protected from personal & business creditors and may be estate tax exempt. A qualified 3rd party plan administrator does the plan administration while an independent trustee holds all assets of the trust. Our Welfare Benefit Plan is supported by a substantial authority legal opinion, which includes all current and relevant case law.
Does your business or practice fit the above profile?
NOW Is
The Time For Your Clients to Consider a WBP
As
A Year End Strategy
The last quarter of the year has typically been the time most advisors
meet with clients who are facing a large tax liability, or who are seeking a
way to contribute more than the current maximum under their qualified plan(s).
Advisors limited by prior tax legislation share their frustration.
There is a plan to alleviate the frustrations of both the CPA/Attorney
and Client. Its design allows
contributions in excess of qualified plan limits.
The payments are tax deductible. Plan
assets are protected from creditors, and, under most circumstances with proper
planning are exempt from estate tax. Distributions
can be taken at any age without penalties.
The program is fully insured and follows the guidelines as established
by the Service and Judicial System.
So
What Is This Strategy?
It is a Multiple Employer Welfare Benefit Plan, created by Congress,
which utilizes the limited exceptions of Section 419A(f)(6) to build benefits
and reduce taxes.
WBP’s
have been around for many years. Welfare
trust benefits are available to LLC, C and S Corporations.
Unlike retirement or deferred compensation plans, the Welfare Benefit
Trust (WBT) provides a unique benefit. In
contrast to the above, which is triggered by the passage of time, the WBT
becomes payable by reference to an event not in control of the recipient.
In a qualified plan or deferred compensation plan,
retirement is the triggering event
The event that triggers the WBT is of an uncertain nature such as
death, disability, health, etc.
What
are the Advantages?
(for
accumulating wealth)
·
Tax deductible contributions
·
Assets accumulate on a tax
deferred basis.
·
Flexible contributions
·
Favorable towards the busi-ness
owner
·
Unlimited contributions
·
No vesting for employees
that prematurely terminate
Are
There Other Plans?
There are other trusts available in the marketing community that look
similar. In fact, they use similar marketing verbage.
The promoters of these trusts imply that their favorable Letter of
Determination offers the business owner a degree of security in the event of
an IRS audit. Let me dispel this
myth of tax exempt status offered by some 501(c)(9) promoters.
A 501(c)(9) determination letter does not cover three critical issues:
(1)
The Deductibility of Employer
Contributions: The determination letter states that no opinion is
expressed or im-plied as to whether the employ-er’s contributions are
deductible under the code.
(2)
The Timing of Contributions and
Taxation: The Letter of
Determination for a 501(c)(9) trust states that no opinion is expressed or
implied as to whether or not there is any provision available under the code
that would permit in-dividuals to exclude from gross income contributions or
pay-ments.
(3)
The determination letter will
not apply if the IRS, on audit, determines that the trust is
discriminatory in operation on an employer by employer analysis.
The Service has stated that the anti-discrimination and prohibited
inurement require- ments of 501
(c) (9) regulations will be applied separately to each employer in a Multiple
Employer 501 (c) (9) Trust. If
one of the participant employers fails to satisfy such require- ments, the
entire trust will lose its tax exempt qualification under Section 501 (c) (9). Further, the Service has concluded that if an employer with a
small number of employees participates in a VEBA and provides a dominant share
of an aggregate benefit to a
prohibited group of employees, the prohibitive inurement test would be
violated. Thus, most if not all, small employers in a 501 (c) (9) trust will
fail the prohibitive inurement test. Failure
to satisfy such tests will result in a termination of a tax exempt status.
In summary, protection offered by some VEBA 501 (c) (9) promoters is a
myth. Please note, a Multiple
Employer VEBA must also comply with Section 419A(f)(6).
There have been numerous articles written regarding Welfare Benefit
Plans. The consensus is, and I
believe as well, that the Death Benefit Only Plan is superior. It doesn’t
suffer from the disadvantages of prior case law, including the June 18, 1997
Booth Case (more on this in future newsletters).
EVALUATION
OF A PLAN SPONSOR
The key is to find a plan possessing the intricate design
characteristics which enables it to fit the limited exceptions of the law.
One must also keep in mind that tax attorneys and CPAs did not create
this tax planning opportunity, Congress did.
As responsible advisors to our clients, we have the obligation to
expose them to this idea and, where applicable, use it. It is the responsibility of the IRS to comply with the tax
policy articulated by our elected representatives until, and if, the
regulations are changed.
It is also the professional advisor’s responsibility to look for a
Welfare Benefit Plan sponsor who reduces to writing and separately addresses
com-plex legal issues. Professionals
should not allow their un-familiarity with the Welfare Benefit Trust to impede
their responsibility to provide clients with the best advice.
Clients who can afford an annual con-tribution of $30,000 or more, are
generally entrepreneurs by nature. They routinely endure risk, provided their
advisors articulate the risk, thus allowing them the opportunity to make an
informed decision.
In this first issue, I invite you to reflect upon this question.
“If, in the appropriate
situation,
we can provide you and your clients with substantial authority for
deductibility of a Welfare Benefit Plan, how much would your clients want to
contribute?”
The
Welfare Benefit Trust
Provides
An Effective
Alternative
Option
1
Owner
receives $100,000 of income
Pays
40% in taxes
Net
Spendable Income $60,000
(can
invest or spend)
Option
2
Implements
A Qualified Plan
Maximum
Contribution $30,000
Option
3
Establish
Welfare Benefit Trust
$100,000
Contribution
Deducted
by the Business
$94,000
$6,000
Owner
Benefits EE
Benefits
NOW Is
The Time For Your Clients to Consider a WBP
As
A Year End Strategy
The last quarter of the year has typically been the time most advisors
meet with clients who are facing a large tax liability, or who are seeking a
way to contribute more than the current maximum under their qualified plan(s).
Advisors limited by prior tax legislation share their frustration.
There is a plan to alleviate the frustrations of both the CPA/Attorney
and Client. Its design allows
contributions in excess of qualified plan limits.
The payments are tax deductible. Plan
assets are protected from creditors, and, under most circumstances with proper
planning are exempt from estate tax. Distributions
can be taken at any age without penalties.
The program is fully insured and follows the guidelines as established
by the Service and Judicial System.
So
What Is This Strategy?
It is a Multiple Employer Welfare Benefit Plan, created by Congress,
which utilizes the limited exceptions of Section 419A(f)(6) to build benefits
and reduce taxes.
WBP’s
have been around for many years. Welfare
trust benefits are available to LLC, C and S Corporations.
Unlike retirement or deferred compensation plans, the Welfare Benefit
Trust (WBT) provides a unique benefit. In
contrast to the above, which is triggered by the passage of time, the WBT
becomes payable by reference to an event not in control of the recipient.
In a qualified plan or deferred compensation plan,
retirement is the triggering event
The event that triggers the WBT is of an uncertain nature such as
death, disability, health, etc.
What
are the Advantages?
(for
accumulating wealth)
·
Tax deductible contributions
·
Assets accumulate on a tax
deferred basis.
·
Flexible contributions
·
Favorable towards the busi-ness
owner
·
Unlimited contributions
·
No vesting for employees
that prematurely terminate
Are
There Other Plans?
There are other trusts available in the marketing community that look
similar. In fact, they use similar marketing verbage.
The promoters of these trusts imply that their favorable Letter of
Determination offers the business owner a degree of security in the event of
an IRS audit. Let me dispel this
myth of tax exempt status offered by some 501(c)(9) promoters.
A 501(c)(9) determination letter does not cover three critical issues:
(1)
The Deductibility of Employer
Contributions: The determination letter states that no opinion is
expressed or im-plied as to whether the employ-er’s contributions are
deductible under the code.
(2)
The Timing of Contributions and
Taxation: The Letter of
Determination for a 501(c)(9) trust states that no opinion is expressed or
implied as to whether or not there is any provision available under the code
that would permit in-dividuals to exclude from gross income contributions or
pay-ments.
(3)
The determination letter will
not apply if the IRS, on audit, determines that the trust is
discriminatory in operation on an employer by employer analysis.
The Service has stated that the anti-discrimination and prohibited
inurement require- ments of 501
(c) (9) regulations will be applied separately to each employer in a Multiple
Employer 501 (c) (9) Trust. If
one of the participant employers fails to satisfy such require- ments, the
entire trust will lose its tax exempt qualification under Section 501 (c) (9). Further, the Service has concluded that if an employer with a
small number of employees participates in a VEBA and provides a dominant share
of an aggregate benefit to a
prohibited group of employees, the prohibitive inurement test would be
violated. Thus, most if not all, small employers in a 501 (c) (9) trust will
fail the prohibitive inurement test. Failure
to satisfy such tests will result in a termination of a tax exempt status.
In summary, protection offered by some VEBA 501 (c) (9) promoters is a
myth. Please note, a Multiple
Employer VEBA must also comply with Section 419A(f)(6).
There have been numerous articles written regarding Welfare Benefit
Plans. The consensus is, and I
believe as well, that the Death Benefit Only Plan is superior. It doesn’t
suffer from the disadvantages of prior case law, including the June 18, 1997
Booth Case (more on this in future newsletters).
EVALUATION
OF A PLAN SPONSOR
The key is to find a plan possessing the intricate design
characteristics which enables it to fit the limited exceptions of the law.
One must also keep in mind that tax attorneys and CPAs did not create
this tax planning opportunity, Congress did.
As responsible advisors to our clients, we have the obligation to
expose them to this idea and, where applicable, use it. It is the responsibility of the IRS to comply with the tax
policy articulated by our elected representatives until, and if, the
regulations are changed.
It is also the professional advisor’s responsibility to look for a
Welfare Benefit Plan sponsor who reduces to writing and separately addresses
com-plex legal issues. Professionals
should not allow their un-familiarity with the Welfare Benefit Trust to impede
their responsibility to provide clients with the best advice.
Clients who can afford an annual con-tribution of $30,000 or more, are
generally entrepreneurs by nature. They routinely endure risk, provided their
advisors articulate the risk, thus allowing them the opportunity to make an
informed decision.
In this first issue, I invite you to reflect upon this question.
“If, in the appropriate
situation,
we can provide you and your clients with substantial authority for
deductibility of a Welfare Benefit Plan, how much would your clients want to
contribute?”
The
Welfare Benefit Trust
Provides
An Effective
Alternative
Option
1
Owner
receives $100,000 of income
Pays
40% in taxes
Net
Spendable Income $60,000
(can
invest or spend)
Option
2
Implements
A Qualified Plan
Maximum
Contribution $30,000
Option
3
Establish
Welfare Benefit Trust
$100,000
Contribution
Deducted
by the Business
$94,000
$6,000
Owner
Benefits EE
Benefits
The
Welfare Benefit Trust
A
Unique Tax Reduction Strategy
THE PROBLEM
Business owners and pro-fessionals
desiring to reduce taxes have been frustrated by the restrictions imposed by
traditional qualified plans. These
limitations restrict the amount of contribution into the Qualified Plan and
the amount of future benefits paid.
What options are available for business owners and profes-sionals to
fund existing insur-ance needs through their busi-ness or practice using tax
de-ductible contributions?
THE
ANSWER: FEW OR NONE!
A SOLUTION
The Welfare Benefit Trust is designed to assist business owners or
professionals achieve tax deferred accumulation, while at the same time
provide for tax deductible insurance premiums.
Section 419A(f)(6) of the Internal Revenue Code permits the creation of
a Multiple Employer Trust, known as a Welfare Benefit
Trust,
that can be implemented to fund a specific benefit.
A properly established trust allows a business or professional
corporation to obtain a current deduction for money contributed. A Welfare Benefit Trust is not subject to Qualified Plan
limits. A Welfare Benefit Trust
provides businesses and professionals with maximum flexibility.
AVAILABILITY
The Welfare Benefit Trust is utilized by LLC, C-Corporations and
S-Corporations. The Trust is supported by legal and tax opinions with
substantial authority and is administered by a highly qualified organization.
WHO SHOULD CONSIDER A WBT?
·
Any profitable business or
professional practice that wants a way to reduce tax liability.
·
Corporations that can no longer
make contributions to their qualified retirement plans because they are
over-funded or no longer favor the business owner.
·
Individuals who have estate
tax
problems and wish to reduce or eliminate inheritance taxes.
·
Individuals who would like to
protect their assets from creditors. Especially
those in a high risk business.
ADVANTAGES
When Fully Insured
Tax
Deductible Contributions.
Assets
Accumulate Tax-Deferred.
Contributions
Are Flexible As To Amount
Favorable
Towards Business Owner.
Protection
of Assets From Creditors (under most circumstances).
Inexpensive
To Set Up And Administer.
Permitted
under the Internal Revenue Code
Unlimited
Contributions.
Survivor
Benefits Are Income Tax Exempt And Can Be Free Of Estate
& Gift Tax.
WHAT IS A
419A(f) (6) MULTIPLE EMPLOYER WELFARE BENEFIT TRUST?
·
A multiple employer trust is
authorized under Section 419A(f)(6) of the Internal Revenue Code. This ‘safe
harbor’ is set up to provide certain types of benefits for employees of the
sponsoring employer.
·
A Welfare Benefit Trust can be
established by virtually any large or small corporation for the benefit of its
employees, including owner-employees. WBT’s are utilized by thousands of
businesses and professionals throughout the country. There are more than 10,000 Welfare Benefit Plans in operation
in the USA today.
(Source:
IRS)
·
Welfare Benefit Trusts are one of
the most powerful wealth preservation
and tax deferral tools allowed
by law.
·
A Welfare Benefit Trust should not
be regarded as a retirement plan or a form of deferred compensation.
·
Contributions are tax deductible
and are not included in current income.
·
Any growth of Welfare Benefit Trust
funds is tax deferred. If withdrawn
from the trust, they are taxed as ordinary income.
WELFARE
BENEFIT PLAN
COMPARISON
|
|
Traditional Pension Plan or 401(k) Plan |
Non-Qualified Deferred Comp. Plan |
Welfare Benefit Plan** |
|
Selectivity
of Participation |
No |
Yes |
Yes |
|
Currently
Deductible Contribution* |
Yes |
No |
Yes |
|
Assets
Protected From Creditors |
Yes |
No |
Yes |
|
Plan
Favorable Towards Owners |
No |
Yes |
Yes |
|
Unlimited
Plan Contributions |
No |
Yes |
Yes |
|
Inexpensive
To Set Up And Administer |
No |
Yes |
Yes |
* Must be reasonable as it relates to W-2 Income.
**
Fully insured.
As
reported in the September 23, 1998 Wall Street Journal, the wealthiest 1 percent
of Americans with income over $229,230 paid almost one-third of the nation’s
total federal individual income taxes in 1996, up
25% a decade earlier. This
elite group earns 16% of America’s income
Professional advisors, CPAs and Attorneys should not allow their
unfamiliarity with new ideas to impede their judgment.
It is your responsibility to provide your clients with innovative
planning tools.
The key is: Education and
Due Diligence. It is the
obligation of a creditable Plan Sponsor of the Welfare Benefit Plan to provide
the advisor with both.
As with any business planning tool, these questions should be answered:
DOES THE PLAN SPONSOR:
·
Provide comprehensive due
diligence?
·
Have a substantial letter of
authority and
address complex legal issues?
·
Conform to all the guidelines as
handed down in Robert D. Booth v. Commissioner,
·
Have legal and knowledgeable professionals to provide current and ongoing
service?
When you are satisfied that you have selected a competent, well organized
plan sponsor and program, one you can recommend with pride and a provider you
can trust, then the next course of action is to ask:
“What is the profile of a Welfare Benefit Plan candidate?”
1.
Small to medium size business or practice
2.
Gross income of $100,000 or more
3.
Clients who want to accumulate substantial assets in excess of pension benefits.
4.
Clients with a fully funded qualified plan
5.
Clients who seek to protect assets from creditors
6.
Clients facing retained earnings or unreasonable compensation problems
7.
Clients who need tax deductible life insurance premiums to
fund estate planning needs
8.
Clients who may have early turnover
Our organization and professional associates are skilled in the design of
tax oriented strategies. We can
help you and your clients in resolving that on going year end question “How
Can I Reduce My Taxes?”
DETERMINING
COMPENSATION IN A C AND S CORPORATION
FOR
BENEFIT PURPOSES
AND
WORST
CASE SCENARIO -- IF CONTRIBUTIONS ARE DISALLOWED
W-2
income is utilized in a C Corporation for determining the multiple for benefit
purposes. It is noteworthy that
when there are several participating shareholders varying in age, compensation
and need, the prohibitive group members, who generally are owners, can opt out
of all or part of the life benefits. This
allows the greatest versatility in planned design.
For
example, all owners may earn the same income but may not want to participant at
the same benefit level. In a C
Corporation, they could simply adjust
their W-2 income for benefit consideration purposes, thus allowing flexibility
of individual choice.
Conversely,
if a shareholder performs services for his/her Sub-S Corporation, draws no
salary, and arranges for the corporation to pay him/her dividends, the IRS will
properly classify those dividends as wages.
REV ruling 74-44, 1974-1 CB287 held that dividends in lieu of salary are
considered wages for FICA, FUTA and withholding tax purposes.
The rulings of several recent district court cases and PLR 7949022 August 79
provide the authority that, if active shareholders receives dividends, K1 or
undistributed taxable income, it constitutes compensation.
As such, we believe all income may be used for purposes of determining
the multiple of benefit in a Welfare Benefit Plan. (For a full explanation,
E-mail, Fax or Call).
A
contribution of $100,000 made by a Sub-S Corporation in the month of November
1998 creates a $40,000 tax saving that pass through to its sole shareholder. If
the owner pays quarterly estimated taxes he/she can reduce his/her estimated
payment by $10,000 per quarter in the following year.
This results in increased cash flow that can be utilized for other
purposes.
Shareholders
of C and S Corporations have asked, “What, in your opinion, is the so-called
‘worst case scenario’ in
the unlikely event the IRS is successful in the disallowance of corporate
contributions?”
Answer:
The
corporation would have to pay income tax on the disallowed amounts in addition
statutory interest for all the years still open under the 3-year statute of
limitations. To the extent the
deductions were claimed more than 3 years subsequent to the year under audit,
those distributions would not generally be susceptible to disallowance.
The
net economic effect of payment of interest could be mitigated by the annual
increase in cash value of the insurance contract.
In most instances, this should exceed the amount of interest paid to the
IRS. Remember, the corporation would have been responsible to pay the same tax had it not adopted the Welfare
Benefit Plan. Under §6662, there
is a 20% accuracy related penalty unless the taxpayer can show reasonable
reliance on an independent opinion by a qualified attorney or advisor.
In
our plan, the taxpayer would be able to demonstrate good cause for claiming the
deduction and the penalties will be abated under §6664(c).
(For full explanation, E-mail, Fax or Call)
During
the contribution phase, the IRS has
a 3 year lookback, during which time the plan may be earning 7%-9% or more.
Remember, a client’s only exposure is his/her tax bracket = 33% to 40%.
During this period of time, the life insurance policy’s cash value has
been growing at the highest current rate on 100% of the corporate contribution
resulting in maximum tax efficiency.
Corporate
Contribution
I
have been in practice for over 31 years. I
cannot recall the IRS designing a significant tax deductible employee benefit
program that would benefit the general public.
Rather, the IRS takes the opposite position.
It attempts to eliminate or control tax deductible ideas that creative
planners have designed based on interpretation of the Code and judicial rulings.
Welfare Benefit Plans are utilized by over 10,000 businesses (source-IRS)
and have been in existence for many years.
A WBP should be well designed to protect the client from any
under-withholding penalty and, if necessary, provide an exit strategy.
By
complying with all laws and regulations governing Welfare Benefit Plans and by
practicing the highest standards of market conduct, we are determined to exceed
the client’s expectations. We
believe this strengthens our competitive advantage and enables us to focus on
what is important.
In
addition, this competitive advantage helps to develop relationships with clients
and their advisors, providing them with appropriate advice, product and service.
It is what is expected from us as experts in our field and it is our goal
to deliver more than what is expected.
A
properly structured Welfare Benefit Plan can deliver;
1.
Large deductible contributions which offer flexibility as to amount
2.
Benefits that favor business
owners and professional
corporations
3.
Assets that accumulate and compound tax
deferred
4.
Protection of assets from creditors
5.
Survivor benefits that are
income tax exempt and can be free of estate and gift tax
6.
No vesting for terminated employees
7.
Distributions at any age without penalty
8.
A safe harbor under the Internal Revenue Code
9.
Reasonable set up and administration fees
10.
A sophisticated asset transfer technique
Our
organization is comprised of a network of professionals who collectively offer a
wide array of experience. This
strategic alliance commits us to setting and maintaining the highest ethical
standards of market conduct and sales practice in the design of tax oriented
strategies.
We
hope you have found our year end newsletters a helpful guide for you and your
clients. There is still time
in 1998 for your client’s to benefit from a year-end deduction
We know that many of you have been concerned about
legislation pending in Congress that would have disallowed the use of permanent
life insurance in a Welfare Benefit Plan. We are your Welfare Benefit Plan
sponsor so be assured that we have been concerned right along with you. But now
the dust has settled, President
Clinton vetoed the Financial
Freedom Act of 1999. Then on
Friday, September 24th a proposal to include such legislation in a package of
so-called “extender” bills was defeated. (Any bill affecting the way the IRS
collects taxes has an absolute deadline of October 7th, after that there is not
enough time to change the necessary forms.)
Finally, GOP leaders appear to have little or no interest in trying to negotiate with the White House,
trading off spending increases for a smaller tax cuts. They want to get out of
town and prepare for next year’s elections.
On To the Next
Millennium
Conventional wisdom holds that the tax cut issue and
“coat-tail” issues, such as the one effecting permanent insurance in
419(a)(f)(6) plans, will not be re-addressed until the Summer of 2001, at the
earliest. At the very least we have three(3) years of deductions: 1999, 2000,
and 2001. This idea, to disallow permanent life insurance in WBP’s, seems to
pop up every few years and is a classic “chilling” tactic used by the IRS to
keep people from taking any action and to intimidate advisors. It follows like
night follows day that the Service is not going to be in favor of an arrangement
that keeps them from getting their hands on your client’s money. Do not be
fooled into doing nothing, or advising others to do nothing...our
Welfare Benefit Plan is alive and well...providing an excellent opportunity
for your high-achieving small business clients to direct a portion of their
income to a “safe harbor.” Using pre-tax dollars, business owners and their
employees can purchase life insurance as part of their business planning, or as
part of their personal estate planning, funding for estate taxes and estate
liquidity. With a properly set up
and administered WBP, death benefits can pass to loved ones completely free of
income and estate taxes...the Service never gets to see the money. Would your
high-achieving clients appreciate such a plan going forward into the new
millennium?
NOW is the Time
to Consider a WBP as a Year End Strategy
The last quarter of the year is typically the time
that most advisors are meeting with clients
who are facing large income tax liabilities. Adviors are “under the
gun,” seeking ways to reduce client’s taxes and thereby increase that
client’s spendable or transferrable wealth. We all start to feel the
frustration of seeing hard-earned dollars lost in the “black hole” of
taxation. We need to disregard the chilling effect of threatened legislation and
ACT. Remember, CPA’s and tax
attorneys did not create the safe harbor offered by 419(a)(f)(6)...Congress did.
It is the law. It is the responsibility of the IRS to comply with the tax policy
articulated by our elected representatives. As responsible advisors, it is our
obligation to educate our clients regarding available tax reduction strategies,
such as tax-deductible life insurance, and where applicable, to seize
the opportunity to utilize such plans to their benefit. A WBP is a win-win
situation. Your client gets an almost unlimited income tax deduction, you get a satisfied customer...and
because life insurance is the funding vehicle, that contribution together with
accruals thereon may never be taxed. Everybody
benefits...except the IRS.
We have referred herein to your high-achieving
business clients. Here is the profile: The client must be a profitable
corporation, able to make
substantial contributions over a period of time, say $30,000 plus, for seven(7)
or more years. The client should be in a position to make such a commitment
without affecting their current life-style.(Groups of professionals are prime
examples) The client must be able to tolerate some risk....A WBP is only
appropriate for clients that do not require an absolute guarantee that
deductions will never be challenged by the IRS. Keep in mind that clients who
can afford an annual contribution of $30,000 or more are usually entrepreneurs
by nature. They know there is never reward without risk. They routinely endure
risk but want that risk articulated and weighed against the opportunity for
reward...they want to make an informed decision. Qualified clients should obtain
a second opinion letter from a qualified tax attorney that evaluates their
specific situation. This letter should not come from the law firm that issued
the WBP’s supporting Tax Opinion. A client-fact specific second opinion letter
should eliminate the possibility of a penalty. Thus, the only risk remaining, if
the deduction is challenged and your client does not want to meet that
challenge, is that the deduction could be disallowed for the three(3) year
“lookback” period . The corporation would be required to pay income taxes on
the disallowed amounts plus interest.
Two
factors mitigate this already minimal risk. First, since the company used
pre-tax dollars to purchase cash-accruing (for the most part) life insurance,
most of those dollars have been working to increase the cash value of
that insurance. The insurance is in a trust and the trust will not have to pay
taxes on its earnings. These earnings will, in most cases, exceed the amount of
interest paid to the Service. And, the
Now That the
Dust Has Settled...Make Hay While the Sun Shines.
Welfare Benefit Plans WBP exist to promote the public
good. It is well settled that an
employer can provide his employees with benefits in excess of mere compensation.
These benefits serve the public purpose of increasing employee loyalty,
stimulating productivity, and affording greater company stability.
Thus, an employer can deduct as a reasonable and necessary business
expense, the cost of providing these benefits.
When the benefit provided is life insurance the IRS
gets its share every year the Plan is in effect because each
employee-participant is responsible to pay taxes on the reportable economic
benefit or PS58 cost of their participation.
Thus, life insurance premiums are deductible by the employer and taxable
to the employee albeit at a lesser rate provided in PS58. This is a logical and
fair exchange, the employee pays a tax on a small amount, i.e. the reportable
economic benefit and receives in exchange a larger tax-free death benefit.
Thus is federal tax policy adhered to in a WBP.
Moreover, when the employee benefit provided is life
insurance, the public good and federal tax policy is served by providing funds
for the security and welfare of the survivors of adverse events such as death,
disability, incapacity, or severe economic downturn. (See Section 101(a) IRC) WBPs promote the public good while
complying with existing federal tax policy objectives.*
What is a Welfare Benefit Plan?
Simply stated it is an employee benefit plan that provides for
circumstances other than retirement or pension benefits.
Welfare benefits can include death benefits, severance pay benefits,
vision benefits medical and disability benefits.
A WBP is not a pension or retirement plan, nor is it a form of deferred
compensation in disguise. A WBP is
a plan that provides a hedge against those unexpected, unforeseeable and
uncontrollable events which all of us face.
Such events as death, long-term disability, incapacity and extreme
business adversity.
The distinction between a Welfare Benefit Plan and a
retirement or deferred compensation plan is found in the event which triggers the payment of benefits. In
the qualified plan or deferred compensation arrangement the triggering event is
either foreseeable or in control of the participant such as retirement or the
reaching of a certain age. In stark
contrast, the triggering event in a WBP is of the uncertain variety…outside
the control of the participant.
This distinction underlies the rationale for the
favorable treatment of Welfare Benefit Plans.
Congress has decided that while some tax revenues may be lost, the
greater public good of providing for the security and welfare of the survivors
of such unexpected adverse events, is realized. Do not forget that the IRS is taxing the premiums year in and
year out pursuant to the PS58 schedule. It
is a win-win situation.
The expected vs. the unexpected event reasoning also
provides the basis for allowing an employer to alter, amend, or terminate a plan
to meet the changing needs of employers and employees.
With regard to termination and the distribution of Plan assets in the
event of termination it should be noted that such distribution is not a plan benefit,
rather it is the incidental result after
plan benefits cease.
In a Welfare Benefit Plan you can mix permanent and
term insurance. This allows
permanent insurance for the most highly compensated employees and term insurance
for others. So long as the benefits
are proportional there is no discrimination.
That is, when each participant’s life insurance policy is the same
multiple of compensation there is no discrimination because should an
participant die while the plan is in force his beneficiary receives the preset
multiple of that participant’s compensation as a death benefit.
This being true, the method chosen to fund the benefit, either term or
permanent life insurance, is irrelevant to the operating characteristics of the
plan. Therefore, the cost of
providing the benefits is not relevant so long as the benefits themselves are a
uniform multiple of compensation.
Further, commonly known actuarial data would seem to
mandate to selection of permanent insurance for key employees.
Data shows that an alarming number of highly paid professionals and
executives suffer disabilities during their working lives. Prime examples are
heart attacks, ulcers and other stress-related disorders.
Such an unexpected event can render said key employee uninsurable and
thus it is prudent business practice to choose permanent life insurance over
term insurance for these employees.
Additionally, if a WBP were to be funded with only
term insurance and the employer should experience an economic slowdown there
might be no monies available to pay premiums and the plan would die.
Everybody loses. On the other hand, a properly designed WBP mixing term and
permanent insurance provides an unallocated reserve from which to draw premium
payments during bad times. The
result is that the plan and its benefits survive.
The public good is again served.
A final word on permanent vs. term insurance as a
funding vehicle for a WBP involves the ownership of policy cash values.
Cash values are owned by the trust and not by the individual
employee-participants. In the event
a plan should be terminated for one reason or another, each participant employed
at the time of termination is entitled a share of the cash value.
This distribution is again proportional and based upon each employee’s
total compensation against which a common multiplier is applied.
A plan is not discriminate just because it provides one type of insurance
to this group of employees and another type of insurance to another group, so
long as all participating employees are eligible for benefits in the same
proportion. This fairness theme
underlies the delivery of benefits in a properly designed Welfare Benefit Plan.
In review, Welfare Benefit Plans exist to serve the
public good by providing funds to meet needs, which arise out of unexpected
adverse events. WBP’s work in
harmony with qualified plans that provide for retirement and pension benefits.
One provides for the planned event while the other provides for the
unexpected emergency. Both are
necessary for continued business stability, growth and prosperity.